    * EN
    * ES
    * PT
  * 
  * 
  * 
  * 
  * 
  * Home
  * ABOUT CEJIL
      + Who we are
      + What we do
      + How we work
      + Strategic Plan 2023-2027
      + CEJIL DEFENDING RIGHTS
      + CLIMATE CHANGE
      + HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENDERS
  * ISSUES
      + Arts and Human Rights
      + Human Rights Defenders
      + Human Mobility
      + International Justice
      + State-Sponsored Violence
      + Indigenous People
      + Women
      + Climate Change
  * NEWS
      + Press Releases
      + Map of Cases
      + SUMMA
      + Multimedia
  * ANALYSIS
      + Blog
      + Publications
  * PARTICIPATE
      + Get Involved
      + Trabaja con Nosotres
      + Internship Program
      + Take Action!
      + The Jonathan Eoloff Fund
  * CEJIL 30 Years
      + CEJIL 30 Years: La Cantuta
      + CEJIL 30 Years: Marco Antonio Molina Theissen
      + CEJIL 30 Years: The Palace of Justice
      + CEJIL 30 Years: Digna Ochoa
      + CEJIL 30 Years: Jineth Bedoya Lima
      + CEJIL 30 Years: Women of Atenco
      + CEJIL 30 Years: Super pollutants in Latin America
  * DONATE NOW
    * Home
    * ABOUT CEJIL
        + Who we are
        + What we do
        + How we work
        + Strategic Plan 2023-2027
        + CEJIL DEFENDING RIGHTS
        + CLIMATE CHANGE
        + HUMAN RIGHTS DEFENDERS
    * ISSUES
        + Arts and Human Rights
        + Human Rights Defenders
        + Human Mobility
        + International Justice
        + State-Sponsored Violence
        + Indigenous People
        + Women
        + Climate Change
    * NEWS
        + Press Releases
        + Map of Cases
        + SUMMA
        + Multimedia
    * ANALYSIS
        + Blog
        + Publications
    * PARTICIPATE
        + Get Involved
        + Trabaja con Nosotres
        + Internship Program
        + Take Action!
        + The Jonathan Eoloff Fund
    * CEJIL 30 Years
        + CEJIL 30 Years: La Cantuta
        + CEJIL 30 Years: Marco Antonio Molina Theissen
        + CEJIL 30 Years: The Palace of Justice
        + CEJIL 30 Years: Digna Ochoa
        + CEJIL 30 Years: Jineth Bedoya Lima
        + CEJIL 30 Years: Women of Atenco
        + CEJIL 30 Years: Super pollutants in Latin America
    * DONATE NOW
    * 
    * 
    * 
    * 
    * 
    IDIOMAS
        * EN
        * ES
        * PT
    * |
    * Press Release
    * |
    * Dominican Republic denies discrimination and collective expulsions before the Inter-American Court
  28 de October de 2013 Press Release

  Dominican Republic denies discrimination and collective expulsions before the Inter-American Court

  Mexico City and Santo Domingo, October 9, 2013 – This Wednesday the public hearing on the case Benito Tide Méndez and others before the Inter-American Court of Human Rights concluded. This case addresses the arbitrary detention and subsequent expulsion of 27 people, the majority of whom are Dominican nationals, and 12 of whom were children at the time of their expulsion.

  The Center for Justice and International Law (CEJIL), Movimiento de Mujeres Dominico-Haitianas (Movement of Dominico-Haitian Women, MUDHA), Groupe d’Appui aux Rapatriés et Réfugiés (Support Group for Refugees and Repatriated Persons, GARR), and Columbia Law School Human Rights Law Clinic acted as representatives for the victims before the Inter-American Tribunal. The hearing was held in Mexico City, during the Inter-American Court’s 48th Period of Ordinary Sessions.

  The representing organizations highlighted the pattern of mass expulsions and the denationalization policy directed at Dominicans of Haitian descent with parents holding an irregular status in the country, showing the Tribunal that the events of the present case did not occur in isolation.

  Francisco Quintana, CEJIL’s Program Director for the Andean, North America and Caribbean Region, mentioned that, “the hearing allowed us to demonstrate the racial discrimination in the treatment of the afro-descendant population, particularly of Haitians and those of Haitian descent.” Quintana further added that it is regrettable that the Dominican State did not respect the right to defense; “in the hearing, the government representative presented evidence in an inappropriate moment and manipulated the statement of the only witness.”

  “Surprisingly, in order to deny racial discrimination, the Dominican State employed elements of nationalism and xenophobia” noted Cristiana Luis Francisca, President of MUDHA. She added that, “the debate will not in end with this hearing; our organizations will continue looking for justice at both the internal level and before international bodies.”

  “The State’s arguments were inconsistent and contradictory in denying the existence of a pattern of collective expulsions, which occurred not only during the period in which the events of this case took place, but are currently being perpetuated”, remarked Paola García Rey from the Columbia Law School Human Rights Law Clinic.

  Likewise, Lisane André of GARR added that, “the repatriations in 1991 gave birth to our work, in a moment when expulsions reached highs of 35 thousand people. We hope that as a result of this case, as the discussed human rights standards are applied and collective expulsions cease, we will be able to put aside this strong aspect of our work.”

  At the close of the hearing the organizations asked that the Court issue a judgment which ensures integral reparation to the victims. In light of the behavior of the State during the hearing, the organizations representing the victims feel that particular importance must be placed on the recognition of international responsibility and the realization of public apology for the events in the case.

  After the hearing, the organizations and the Dominican State must present their final written arguments within a month, respectively. A decision is expected from the Inter-American Court by the beginning of the next year.

  The hearing was transmitted live and can be accessed on the Inter-American Court’s website www.corteidh.or.cr.

      * 
      * 
      * 


Related content

      Statement Regarding Attacks on the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights

      Ecuador: national and international organisations call on the National Court of Justice to guarantee due process and put a stop to the criminalisation of environmental defenders

              Support human rights, defend justice

              Help us continue this critical and urgent work with a donation!

                DONATE NOW

              Issues

              Human Rights Defenders

              Human Mobility

              International Justice

              State-sponsored Violence

              Indigenous People

              Women

              Climate Change

              More about CEJIL

              Learn about our historical work

              Meet the Board of Directors of our offices

              FAQs

              Conflicts of interest

              Press inquiries

              Get Involved

              Receive our latest updates in your e-mail.

                SUBSCRIBE

              This site is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution – Non-Commercial – No Derivative Works 3.0 Unsupported | Privacy Policy

                Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin Instagram